LunarCast Network

[Home] [Replay Archive] [File Server] [Settings]

Entity Component Interface System

A new way to design component systems

Discord Server:

What is this:
This is a design doc for a new game design architecture I am developing based on the Entity Component System for use in Danmakufu Remake

The flaws of existing systems:
ECS has some flaws, first it exposes components as raw data making it difficult to change the underlying component structure, second it assumes or likes to assume that each component has one system, however in practice each system controls multiple components, one bearing the name of the system and others with related data, how are you supposed to classify these ? home and "roaming" components? Also sometimes for the sake of performance its better to split a component into smaller components with related data however still be under 1 system.

[Flaws of the ECS System diagram]
In the above diagram, we have an example entity, the Curved Laser which has Transform, Movement and Texture2D components among others.

The first flaw that can be seen is the Transform Component and System, because all the Transform component does is store the position of an Entity in world space, it does not need to be updated and does not need a system. This means that certain components might not have systems!
The second flaw is the Movement System, as it utilizes both the Transform and Movement components. Is the component with the same name as the system "special" in any way towards it? Is that the "Home" component and the others are "Roaming" or "Guest" components?
Additionally, there is the Texture2D Component which like the Transform Component does not have a system, however it is used by the Render System, which is able to render entities bearing both a Texture2D and UVMesh Component or a RGBAMesh component, none of which have System bearing their name but are used exclusively by the Render System.
The last and most important flaw is that this ECS system exposes the structure of the Components to the rest of the code, as it has to interface both with individual components by setting their values and with the systems themselves for performing operations involving multiple (or all) entities and components.

The solution to the issues of the ECS system is the Entity Component Interface System or ECIS, which completely decouples components from their "manager" systems and the game code from the Systems.

The Entity Component Interface System redefines the meaning of components and systems:
Components are primarily bundles of tightly coupled data which give an entity a trait or property. Additionally Components are the common denominator of duplicated data between two components. (Example: Movement and Collider both need a position, instead of duplicating the position data it is separated into a standalone component that both utilize.)
Systems perform continuous or on-demand global actions on a specific set of components and are not coupled to a specific component. (Example: The Motion System operates on the "Movement" and "Transform" components continuously to provide movement, and also has on-demand functions to slow/stop all entities.) If an entity does not have the correct set of compatible components the system simply ignores it.

The Entity Component Interface System defines and additional concept:
Interfaces are bundles of logically related functions for interacting with a particular concept the ECS system supports. (Example: The Movement & Motion Interface provides functions for setting and changing an individual object's velocity and also for slowing or accelerating all objects) (Additional example: The Position Interface provides functions for setting and retrieving an Entity's transform)

[ECIS architecture diagram]

LunarCast Network